Charlottesville: Responses to Tragedy

On Aug. 13, the day after violent demonstrations and counter-demonstrations in Charlottesville, Virginia, the leaders of Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church responded. Senior Pastor Scott Black Johnston wrote a special message to the congregation, which members and friends received in their email early Sunday morning. Our parish associate, the Rev. J.C. Austin, also responded to Charlottesville in his sermon that day. And Executive Pastor Charlene Han Powell delivered the Prayers of the People with the events of Charlottesville as her focal point.

You can listen to J.C.'s sermon, "Marked for Life," and Charlene's prayer in our sermons archive. Or you can read and download the sermon and prayer here.

Scott's message appears below.


From the same mouth comes blessing and cursing. My brothers and sisters, this ought not to be so.—James 3:10

Dear Friends in Christ:

Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me. It's the first rhyme a child learns on the playground. It is a feisty, singsong response to an insult.

It is also a big, fat lie.

Words hurt. Words demean, threaten and abuse. Words paint twisted pictures of our sisters and brothers. Words fan the flames of anger. Words condone violence.

When sticks and stones get picked up, it is usually because of words.

My friends, I lament the images emerging from Charlottesville, Virginia. I know you do, too. I condemn the vile words used by white nationalists who marched there this weekend. I know you do, too.

The rhetoric of this movement is utterly toxic. It scapegoats the same people fascists always seem to target: Jews and Catholics, African Americans and Latinos, LGBT persons and women. The leaders of this movement cast an ugly vision for our country. The words they use are built on fear, anger and pain.

This movement is wrong. It is sinful. It is evil. It must be resisted by people of faith.

How should we resist? I suggest we start by cleaning up our language. We, the people of this proud country, have a diminished appreciation for the harmful and hurtful effects of our words.

This problem starts at the highest level of national politics and descends all the way to junior high school. Too often our words—important words about vital things—are tossed around with little care for either their truthfulness or their power. We are all paying the price for such brutish communication. Our societal conversation has devolved, it has sunk, into a mean-spirited debate in which no one can agree on the facts, and everyone seems eager to play the victim.

There is an alternative. It is rooted in our faith.

Now, more than ever, we need words tempered by prayer, spoken in song, and relentlessly doused with love.

We need prayer because our hearts need to change. We need to understand and not dismiss the pain and anger in our brothers and sisters. This can only come through hearts opened to the grace of God through prayer. Do not discount time spent with your head bowed. Prayer really can move mountains. Sometimes the mountain is us!

We need to sing because this is how people of faith cast a common vision. When we sing the psalms and hymns of our faith, we speak God's majestic vision, a vision that is welcoming and hopeful and beautiful. We need this vision right now.

We need to love because this is the most basic demand Jesus makes of those who would follow him. Without love, we are nothing. Yes, in turbulent times like this, love is challenging. It is also in short supply. Perhaps that is why it is Christ's supreme commandment.

I will be praying for all of you in the days ahead. I will be singing while you are singing this morning. And my heart is full of love for you. I am confident you will make a difference through your caring actions and your mighty words in the days to come.

Bless you and see you soon,


Scott Black Johnston
Senior Pastor


This entry was posted in General News

Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church